Sunday, April 25, 2010

Fools Crow: Final Thoughts

Something that I kept noting throughout the novel was the differing styles of leadership and how each leader's different mode of operation affected the tribe. It reminded me of the show Lost. I don't know if anyone watches the show, but Fools Crow kept reminding me of the different leadership displayed on the show. A leader's view on the importance of the individual versus the overall wellness of the whole group is crucial to how that group functions and how it view its leader. Fools Crow regularly places value in the whole group over his own self. And the willingness to do so involve the talent of foresight. Realizing consequences and adjusting plans with the future in mind is what makes being a leader so difficult. It's default human nature to live and act in the here and now, to have sudden reactions based on emotion. That's why only one of the major players in Fools Crow is depicted as the most effective leader, Fools Crow. Fast Horse and Owl Child both are depicted as hot heads and ineffective leaders because of their reactionary methods.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Polygyny

A small, but interesting element of some of the cultures we've read about is the presence of polygyny, a man having two or more wives. We briefly see it with Running Fishers father, and I recall seeing it in The Way to Rainy Mountain. I researched this kind of marriage a little bit and can really only find scientific explanations: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygyny. What are some more personal reasons for exercising polygyny?

Sunday, March 21, 2010

What I'd Like to Ask James Welch

Reading through the first third of Fool's Crow I keep finding myself imagining the conversation I would have with James Welch. I think that it's incredible how Welch transfers not only the language of the 1800s Black Foot Indians to a modern novel, but also the perspective of 1800s Black Indians to a modern novel. I'm curious to the challenges that doing so presented. Depicting perspective that is different from my own is something that I've struggled with as a writer. I'd love to hear how Welsh accomplished his wonderfully believable point of view seen in Fool's Crow.

Fool's Crow: Initial Thoughts

Fool's Crow is the first novel so far in this class in which a modern story isn't present. In Love Medicine, Ceremony, and The way to Rainy Mountain the ancient and the mythical are paralleled with a modern story. Fool's Crow so far is an old story. But, the dated events and characters are still poignant to today's readers.

At the beginning of chapter six White Man's Dog is described to "... had settled down into the routine of the winter camp but there were days when he longed to travel, to experience the excitement of entering enemy country." That aspect of the character of White Man's Dog resonated with me. Especially after all this winter blah. I've settled into my winter routine, and I want some excitement now.

The story of Fool's Crow is still relatable despite it taking place in the past. Does anyone else have examples of relating to Fool's Crow?

Sunday, February 28, 2010

Epilogue

The culmination of Momaday's blending of story telling voices is the epilogue. The description of the Leonid meteor shower is historical, legendary, and personal. The seamless sewing together of these three perspectives is what I think oral culture triumphs at.

Neither in poetry or prose (other than what I've read in this class) have I seen such an effective use of language to make known the mind of a whole people through their entire history. That is why The Way to Rainy Mountain is considered an epic.

Blending Sections

When starting The Way to Rainy Mountain I was intrigued by the three section format. The sections of legend, history, and anecdote all had well defined borders between one another. But, a common thread is present through each perspective. A thread that drew the three forms of story telling together until I wasn't able to definitely label any the way I could at the beginning of the book.

A beautiful thing happened: the legendary water beast from the myth section stepped into the anecdotes of Momaday and left tracks for his grandfather to see. Momaday's grandfather's grandfather was personally and visibly affecting the history of the Kiowas. And other voices merged. Legend, history, and story all blended into one.

Sunday, February 21, 2010

Momaday video

Momaday's such a genius story teller. I love how combines poetry with his personal stories and history. Even his work with Billy the Kid was wonderful in verse.

A Haunting Passage

A line that stayed with me through the reading of the first half of this book is on page 8. It has to do with Devil's Tower: "Two centuries ago, because they could not do otherwise, the Kiowas made a legend at the base of the rock." That "because they could not do otherwise" intrigues me. I'm having trouble realizing what this means exactly. It's clearly a deliberate passage, and I think it's relevant to the work to understand it. Is it saying that the Kiowa people were destined to be story teller? Any thoughts?

The Purpose of The Way to Rainy Mountain

Last year I took a class on the literature of C.S. Lewis, and the discussion of oral culture and history keeps reminding me of one of Lewis' works, Out of the Silent Planet.

Out of the Silent Planet takes place on Mars where three different species live in perfect harmony with each other and the planet. Each specie excels at an important part of keeping the civilization functioning. The following quote is said by a hrossa, the historians and poets of the planet.
Hmān means human. The seroni are the scientists and inventors of the planet.

"A pleasure is full grown only when it is remembered. You are speaking, Hmān, as if the pleasure were one thing and the memory another. It is all one thing. The séroni could say it better than I say it now. Not better than I could say it in a poem. What you call remembering is the last part of the pleasure, as the crah is the last part of a poem. When you and I met, the meeting was over very shortly, it was nothing. Now it is growing something as we remember it. But still we know very little about it. What it will be when I remember it as I lie down to die, what it makes in me all my days till then–that is the real meeting. The other is only the beginning of it."

The way Momaday's Grandmother is described and remembered through the introduction reminded me of this quote. Even after she's passed away, the memory of Aho is vivid and seems likes it's fulfilling for Momaday to recount. And I think that's a part of the importance of the format of The Way to Rainy Mountain and all oral history and myth. Memories, history, myth all start to become one, a part of a person or people. The event or person recounted isn't a completely separate entity from the memory. The memory of the thing is the fulfillment of it.

The concept of oral tradition fascinates me, and I'm loving examining it the different books we're reading!

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Dear Night Swan

Dear Night Swan,
If I may, I would like to ask you some questions about who you are. I don't mean your physical description, (I've heard plenty about that already) but your character, your core. I was wondering what it's like to exist in such a mixed culture. It has to be hard. But, I understand you can be very persuasive when you want to be. I heard about you convincing Josiah to invest in those cattle.

I am curious (let me know if I'm prying) what you were really after in that relationship with Josiah?

I heard about Tayo.

The Shape of Poetry

From the discussion of a previous post, I realized that the physical shape of the poetry in Ceremony contributes massively to the story. I wrote in the discussion :

Most of the poems, I think, have a sort of beautiful subtlety to them. The shape of that poem on page 119 also caught my attention, but I wasn't really conscience of why. My eye was trying to communicate to my mind, but I wasn't sure of what. I had to go back to re-analyze some of the poems for that "visual poetry." It was astonishing at what the poems could do now. There's a clear issue with transcribing oral culture to paper pages, but Silko did an incredible job of doing so. Mannerisms, delivery, and timing are all a part of oral story telling. All are very subtle, simple, and maybe even subconscious elements, but very important nonetheless. Through subtle visual poetry, I think Silko accomplished as effectively as possible the expression of oral culture.

Look at the poem on page 53, for example. The page 53 poem's concrete formatting is thin and chaotic. And, so is the story that it's reciting. If the page 53 poem's story was shared orally the delivery from the speaker would demonstrate what the poem's form is accomplishes.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

My First Reaction

I've never experienced a book like Ceremony. The format is unique but effective. I love the poetry so far. Even something as simple as no chapter divisions adds to narrative and sometimes mythical feel of the novel. I look forward to finishing it next week!

Sunday, January 31, 2010

June

June is my favorite character from the book. I thought it was so unique who Erdich made her one of the main characters, if not the main character. The text centered around her, even though she wasn't present in the strictest sense for the vast majority of the story. I loved how June's life affected so many others in so many diverse ways. That kind of relationship web reminded me of stories like the one in Forest Gump. No matter whom the characters touched, that person walked away forever altered. For the better. I don't like June or Forest were aware of how they were forever impacting lives, but it was something they excelled at. I strive to be that kind of person in real life. Mother Teresa said, "Let no one ever come to you without leaving better and happier." Despite what the outside influences of alcohol, and poverty, and exploitation may have had on June, it only affected her outside, her skin. June Morrissey was a beautiful person on the inside, and that's evident by the way life impacted others'.

Saturday, January 30, 2010

a difficult read

I hope I'm not alone in saying that this was a difficult read. Not in themes, imagery, or voice (which weren't simple by any means), but in the elements of the plot. With the timeline I often found myself mired in revising my notes. The relationships between each character caused this as well. But, reading other's post definitely helped along with the other posted resources. I know I couldn't have made it through Love Medicine without taking extra time to re-read passages and using my classmates thoughts. Despite my confusion, I still appreciate the organic unity Erdich accomplished within her work. The unifying property of love, the death of the skin then rebirth of the true self, the complexity of family, the way a single life can affect so many people all were demonstrated consistently within the text. Overall, Love Medicine is definitely a worthwhile read. I'm glad I took extra time while reading it.

Sunday, January 24, 2010

Erdich's Style

The multiple points of view used by Erdrich, I think, does something interesting. Different characters are affected by different things in different ways. And hearing about other characters from a single character through the whole novel can't accomplish what a first person account can do. Also, on the same token, hearing about a character from another character can do something unique. Different characters sometimes have a clearer understanding than that character has of him or herself. For example, Albertine's understanding the gravity of Eli receiving King's World's Best Fisherman hat.

A Theme

As I read through the chapters of Love Medicine, I can't help but notice the presence of the imagery of skin. The first section that introduced June repeated how her skin appeared and affected by life. But, her inside was compared to nature, the cold spring air. I kept noticing that inside versus out theme throughout the text so far. Marie's story of her time at the convent shows the affect of Catholicism on the Native American culture. The imagery of jeweled skin suggests that outward appearance becomes more important than the unity of nature on the inside.

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Hello everyone...

I'm new to blogging, but the more I see of it, the more I like it. I'm looking forward to using as a tool in this class.